Skip to content
Lawsuit Help Desk

Lawsuit News Center

Decoding the Enigma of High CPU Usage in Magento: The DISTINCT Operator Conundrum

Decoding the Enigma of High CPU Usage in Magento: The DISTINCT Operator Conundrum

"Decoding the Enigma of High CPU Usage in Magento: The DISTINCT Operator Conundrum"
In the world of ecommerce, the efficiency of a platform is a critical determinant of success, with Magento being a top choice for many. However, a recurring issue of high CPU usage has been plaguing users across different versions of Magento, notably tied to a query involving a DISTINCT operator. This insightful exploration, "Decoding the Enigma of High CPU Usage in Magento: The DISTINCT Operator Conundrum," aims to delve into the complexities of this problem, its impacts on performance, and potential solutions to this conundrum.

Dismantling the Query: Unraveling the Impact of the DISTINCT Operator

The Magento platform has been consistently noted for a query involving a DISTINCT operator that has been responsible for high CPU usage. This enigma revolves around the query: SELECT DISTINCT COUNT(*) FROM search_query. Evidently, the larger the search_query table, the slower the query execution due to the DISTINCT operator. Its function is to remove duplicate entries from sets of results, but in this case, it has been found to be not only unnecessary but detrimental to performance.

The search_query table already has a unique constraint on query_text and store_id, rendering the DISTINCT operator redundant. Removing this operator from the equation can significantly improve query performance. This was illustrated when removing the DISTINCT operator from queries within the Magento\Search\Model\ResourceModel\Query\Collection. The queries became more efficient, relieving strain on the database and reducing the high CPU usage.

Magento's Performance Paradox: When High-Speed Commerce Slows Down

The paradox of Magento's performance issue lies in its fundamental purpose: to deliver a high-speed commerce platform. When a query slows down, it directly impacts the efficiency of the platform, slowing down not only internal processes but also user interactions. For instance, the query duration increased with the size of the search_query table. This slowdown was especially noticeable when making a query in the main search bar, which took an unreasonable amount of time, exacerbating user frustration.

Moreover, this issue has been reported across various versions of Magento, from 2.3.4 to 2.4.6-p1. Even with the enablement of Elasticsearch, a distributed, open-source search and analytics engine, the performance issue persisted. The evidence compiled points to a distinct issue within the Magento platform, one that contradicts its core value of high-speed commerce.

A High-Priority Enigma: User Experiences and Magento's Response

This performance issue has been marked as a high priority on Magento's backlog, given its widespread occurrence and impact on user experience. Multiple users have reported experiencing the same performance issue, with inefficiencies observed even on the latest 2.4-develop branch.

The issue is not merely an internal concern, but conspicuously visible to the end-user. For instance, the search suggestion feature, a critical aspect of user interaction, was found to impact MySQL performance significantly. Despite these concerns, disabling search suggestions did not prevent hits on the search_query table, indicating the problem's rooted deeper in the system.

In response, Magento has acknowledged the issue, marking it as a high priority for resolution. However, the solution isn't as straightforward as it seems. The code change in c90edaa was suggested as a patch, but it might not wholly address the performance issue. Further evaluation and innovation are necessary to truly resolve this high-priority enigma.

The Persistent Problem: Understanding the Relevance in Latest Magento Versions

Despite the introduction of various solutions, the problem of high CPU usage due to the DISTINCT operator persists across multiple versions of Magento. In Magento 2.4.1-p1, the same performance bug was observed, suggesting an underlying issue that transcended version upgrades. The problem did not discriminate between community and commerce editions of Magento, affecting both the 2.3.4 community version and the 2.4.4-p2 edition. This issue also extended to the latest 2.4-develop branch, accentuating the persistent nature of the problem.

Notably, the high CPU usage was still observed even when Elasticsearch, a high-performance, full-text search engine, was enabled. This indicated that the issue is not limited to MySQL, but is also present with other database management systems, suggesting a deeper, more pervasive problem within the Magento platform. Also, the admin panel was reported to be slowing down due to the problematic query, creating an undesirable user experience for backend administrators.

Beyond the DISTINCT Operator: Future Directions in Magento Performance Optimization

The DISTINCT operator problem presents an opportunity for Magento to rethink its overall performance optimization strategies. The current situation suggests that there might be a need to analyze and optimize other SQL operators and functions within the Magento platform, as the DISTINCT issue might be just the tip of the iceberg.

For instance, given that the search_query table already had a unique constraint on query_text and store_id, the DISTINCT operator was redundant and affected query performance. Perhaps a comprehensive review of the underlying database schema might be necessary to ensure that operators are used in an optimal manner, and redundant ones are eliminated, improving query performance.

Moreover, the idea of asynchronously inserting search terms in batches or inserting only a fraction of search terms could reduce the database load and mitigate performance impact. While these strategies may result in loss of visibility into user search behaviors, they could be necessary trade-offs in the quest for optimal performance.

Future Directions in Magento Performance Optimization

The current DISTINCT operator issue underscores the importance of continuous testing and optimization for Magento. As e-commerce expands and evolves, platforms like Magento need to ensure they remain robust, efficient, and user-friendly.

Potential improvements could include introducing more efficient ways of handling large-scale data, such as off-loading some of the heavy database operations to more capable systems like Elasticsearch, or employing machine learning to predict user search behaviors, thereby reducing the load on the database.

Lastly, Magento could consider a wider community engagement strategy, where users are not just reporting issues but also contributing to solutions. Open-source platforms thrive on their community, and Magento is no different. Harnessing the collective wisdom of the Magento community could be the key to resolving pervasive performance issues and optimizing the platform for the future.

In conclusion, while the DISTINCT operator issue is a significant challenge for Magento, it presents an opportunity for the platform to enhance its performance optimization strategies and engage more actively with its user community. The future of Magento lies not just in solving existing problems, but in foreseeing and addressing potential performance issues before they become problematic.
Thus, we find ourselves at a crossroads in the journey of Magento's performance optimization. The DISTINCT operator issue, while burdensome, unveils an opportunity for deeper introspection into Magento's structural mechanics and an opening for significant enhancement. Future strategies may encompass:

  • A detailed analysis and optimization of SQL operators and functions within the Magento framework, rooting out redundancies and improving performance.
  • A shift towards asynchronous insertion of search terms in batches or limiting the number of search terms to alleviate database pressure.
  • Exploring more efficient data handling methodologies like off-loading heavy database operations to systems like Elasticsearch or employing machine learning to anticipate user search behavior, lightening the database load.

Moreover, the emphasis should be on bolstering community engagement, encouraging users to not only report issues but also contribute to solutions. This could unlock the collective wisdom and creativity of the Magento community, potentially leading to innovative ways of resolving performance challenges and enhancing the platform's efficiency. In conclusion, the DISTINCT operator quandary, despite its challenges, is a stepping stone for Magento to improve its performance optimization strategies, engage with its users more constructively, and prepare for a future where potential performance issues are anticipated and addressed proactively.